Thursday, 9 June 2011

Compromise?

My friend came back into the studio. Seeing my utter dejection, she asked what had happened. Sean came back into the studio. My work still had not been signed off. My friend asked if we couldn't compromise on the open sound? Sean had mentioned two empty studios. My friend offered to pay for and provide the carpenters for the installation of my work in one of those, in order to have my film presented in the way it was intended throughout the process.  Sean flatly refused as this would mean calling back the Health & Safety officers and did I want to risk jeopardising the whole Degree Show?  Of course not.

I asked him if, for my assessment on the following Tuesday, the examiners could see my film with open sound as the other artists wouldn't be involved. Again this was out of the question as the presentation for the assessment has to be consistent with that of the Degree Show.

Sean asked me at what distance from the screen I wanted the headphones to reach. He told me to position my mobility scooter and decide. I asked him where I would get headphones from?  He told me to go to see Boris, the technician. He left the studio. I moved backwards and forwards on my mobility scooter but the whole thing was becoming a blur. My friend asked if we should go to Currys to buy headphones. They would need to be PAT tested before I could be signed off and, by then, Sean had told us Boris the technician was off sick. Sean came back into the studio bearing a set of headphones and we thanked him. We now had to get off to B&Q to source a hook.  Sean signed off my work.  It wasn't the best way to remember hand-in day!

A Sleepless Weekend
It wasn't until that night that I realised all the implications of this change in presentation of my work:
I really felt that Sean had held a gun to my head. I was coerced into agreeing to the use of headphones because of a) the 'problem' had to be resolved before sign-off. The deadline had already passed. b) There was no reasoning with Sean. His decision was made. c) There was no compromise as Sean had pointed out that bringing Health & Safety in again could compromise the whole show.
  • In the 2000 word illustrated document I handed in I had made no mention of headphones anywhere. I had an entire section on presentation and sound. Did that not look like an oversight on my part that I had omitted to mention headphones? I also had a section on 'professional use of my film'.  Wouldn't the examiners think it odd that I intended to show it to groups as the basis for an art workshop through headphones? It was never at any stage my intention to use headphones consequently I made no reference to them.
  • My presentation was due the following Tuesday, before which there was no time to appeal about this headphones ruling.  I had no idea as to what my student rights were. Was I entitled to a student advocate? I was beginning to feel really sick.
  • I felt that my work was being unfairly penalised because it simply didn't suit three other students out of the entire student body. Isn't this a form of censorship? Other people who had sound installations were permitted the use of open sound.  There should  be a blanket policy - either no open sound for anyone or reasonable sound permitted for everyone. I was the only student with an audio installation penalised in this way. Was this flouting equal opportunity rulings?
  • Then there was the logistics of the Show itself. My film lasts 5 minutes give or take. Using headphones, only one person can watch it at a time. No other person's work is limited to an audience of one. How would Ian react if only one person at a time were permitted to enter his 'particpatory art installation' and the rest ushered to wait behind a barrier? Who is going to be prepared to wait in line for the use of the headphones?
  • There is also the issue of the viewer's engagement with the piece.  I had planned for months how to present it with the greatest impact.  The music is integral to the piece.  Every image is synchronised to match the ryhthm of the music. Take that away and you only have half a film. You have changed the dynamic of the piece and the interaction between viewer and work.
  • I was seriously worried about my presentation to examiners the following Tuesday.  Sean insisted that the presentaiton for the assessment had to be consistent with that of the Show. How was I going to present my work when it is in a different format to what I had planned all along? Was I going to pretend that the headphones weren't there or was I going to pretend that I'd planned to present it that way?
I really felt the need for some sound advice.  That weekend I made some useful contacts.

Result!  It pays to know people who know people in high places. Due to the community educational art projects I have been involved with, I have quite a few contacts in academia. They felt that Sean's action was outrageous and passed me on to whoever they thought might be useful in this situation. By Monday afternoon I received confirmation that a meeting was being called between myself, Sean and John Butler, Head of BIAD for Tuesday. It was to take place after my scheduled presentation assessment but I was grateful to have this meeting so soon as I don't think I could have dealt with the anxiety much longer.

Presentation to Internal Examiners
If any BCU students with a problem read this, take heart. I went in with my points prepared in a statement. John Butler allowed my friend to sit in with me. I did not want her to contribute other than in a supporting role because my nerves were in shreds from lack of sleep and food.  I was allowed to read my statement and then Sean had his right to reply. I offered the compromise of only showing my film with open sound once every half hour. Sean made no response. John Butler gave me a fair hearing. Whatever the outcome, I feel that the decision will be made by fair-minded people.

Wednesday, 8 June 2011

Instant decisions

I began to justify my use of music - which I have outlined throughout my blog posts - but it fell on deaf ears. Sean had decided that the use of headphones would be a preferable way to present my film. I was stunned.  Throughout all the previous group crits, informal discussions, tutorials and emails, there had never been mention of headphones to present the film. I asked if I could think about it. Sean said that until this 'problem' was solved I could not sign off my work- the 1.00pm deadline had already passed. Feeling totally intimidated and pressured, I conceded to headphones. Sean then asked me how I wanted to present them. A pedestal? a hook? I had taken months over decisions regarding the engagement of the viewer with my work, now I was expected to make instant decisions about something I had never even considered before. The other three students left the studio, then Sean made his exit. I was left there in stunned silence.

Now here's the problem...

Sean and myself waited for the other three, who arrived together. He began by saying that our pieces worked really well together. Kayleigh's work depicts war and military machinery which has a huge carbon footprint, Ian's piece is made of shiny plastic, which appears in my film, Carly has three paintings of Hollywood actresses and film at that time used harmful chemicals and film is cinematic and my film is about the environment and shown on a screen. I was wondering where this was all leading and then Sean asked, 'is there anything that doesn't work?' to which Ian replied 'the music'. My music. It turned out that my music was contentious because it impacted upon the viewing of their work. Given the fact that we had a hand-in deadline at 1.00pm I felt it was a bit late in the day to raise this matter.

Hand-in deadline shock!

On Thursday 2 June, I went into college for the first time since the Bank Holiday re-opening.  I was impressed at the work going on in the studios. All the walls had new display areas built by the technicians and painted white by the students.  The technicians, Graham, Boris and Pete were busy building my TV installation. It comprises two panels of MDF about 6 feet tall by 4 feet wide. They had concealed the wiringand were on the final stages of screwing down the side struts. They told me it had taken since Tuesday to install because of all the precise measurements.  Because of my broken leg, Sean had overseen the locating of my TV installation and he had done me proud. My friend, who had transported me in, because I am still unable to walk, painted the panels white ready for the TV to be installed. I was to share a studio with Ian, who was constructing in situ a framework with reflective plastic panels for his 'participation art' piece, Carly, who had mounted three paintings of actresses from scenes in old movies and Kayleigh, whose embroidery work was a comment on Guantanamo Bay interns. As we left the paint drying on Thursday, I felt a sense of 'almost there'.  It was just a question of putting the finishing touches to the paintwork, mounting the plasma TV screen, plugging in my memory stick and my film was ready to go for the hand-in deadline the next day at 1pm.  Months and months of work and just one day away from hand-in.

Friday 3 June.  Hand-in day. 
There was a buzz in all the studios when I arrived at 10.00 on Friday.  Ian came over to me and said there was a problem with my sound installation, had I received his email last night? I thought he meant that there was a technical problem with the wiring. I had looked at Moodle and my emails at 9.00pm the previous evening before going to bed, after putting the finishing touches to my report - nothing new.
Sean called to me from a platform in the far corner of the studio that there was an objection to my sound from the other studentssharing the studio. He cupped his hand over his ears and said 'emails have been flying about'. He said he was convening a meeting for the four of us at 12.35 after the Health & Safety officers had left. I could see that he was up to his eyes in it, so I made myself busy in the meantime. I saw the other three students from my studio go off into a room together. I looked around the studios on my mobility scooter. Sean told me not to be conspicuous as he feared the Health & Safety officers might find a problem. He needn't have worried as there was ample space for me to move and where there wasn't, I asked students to move their personal belongings. I went off to find myself a quiet corner, out of the way. I worked with Steve on drawing up a sheet with turn on/off instructions for the artists who were using equipment. Steve is another student working on a film. His film is about violence in an asylum. He is really into goth.  His work has come on hugely over the three years of the course. Sean gave the thumbs up that the Health & Safety officers had given the all clear and I made my way to the disabled platform to be ready for the group meeting.

Saturday, 28 May 2011

The plaster cast comes off!

On Wednesday the day arrived to have my cast removed.  Fingers crossed that the X-ray showed that leg was healing in the three places it was broken. The removal of the cast was pretty scary, but I was assured that the circular saw was completely safe! 

 I have been kitted out with a boot which can bear weight but I still need to use crutches. I was quite shocked at how swollen the leg is still. The consultant said it could be up to a year before it returns to normal. I had a lovely long shower to remove six weeks worth of dead skin. Then I moisturised with olive oil. Just being out of the confinement of that heavy cast and allowing the air to the skin is wonderful!

Session 3 - Litter Art workshop

The girls at King Edward V1 Handsworth School have excelled once more. Given the brief to construct 3D marine fossils which in their lifetime ingested plastic litter, the girls have produced really imaginative art. This is all began with my film, 'The Plight of the Albatross' which they watched. We discussed the issue of irresponsible disposal of litter and set to work.

Monday, 23 May 2011

Great response to my film!

I finalised my 'Plight of the Albatross' film on Friday. I took it into the dance studio of King Edward V1 Handsworth School to watch on the 40" plasma TV.  There were some girls in there having a final after-school dance rehearsal before their GCSE exam on Tuesday. After they had finished their session I played the film for my own viewing. One by one they turned round and began to watch it. They seemed mesmerized by the images. When it had finished they broke into a round of applause and one student said she felt like crying. Another described it as 'wicked!'  I felt really proud of my work. It has involved hours and hours of editing to pull it all together. It was the first time I had seen it on the big screen and it really is breathtaking.

I just hope it evokes the same response in the examiners!